Object of the Week May 18, 2014 The Flattest Galaxy NGC 4762

Object of the Week May 18, 2014 The Flattest Galaxy NGC 4762

NGC 4762, UGC 8016, MCG +02-33-033, Paper-Kite Galaxy
Edge-on Lenticular Galaxy
RA: 12h 52m 56s Dec: +11° 13′ 49″
Size: 8.7’ x 1.7
Mag: 10.0v


NGC 4754, UGC 8010, MCG +02-33-030
Lenticular Barred Galaxy
RA: 12h 52m 18s Dec: +11° 18′ 50″
Size: 4.6’ x 2.5
Mag: 10.3v


The galaxy pair NGC 4762 and NGC 4754 is easy to find for scopes of almost all sizes under reasonably dark skies, even though they are part of the Virgo galaxy cluster. Start at 3rd magnitude ε Virginis (Vindemiatrix), located on the eastern side of the Virgo cloud. From there, move about 2° west and slightly north. You’ve arrived – just look for an extremely thin, yet reasonably bright, edge-on galaxy – this is NGC 4762. In the same field about 11’ northwest you’ll find NGC 4754, a face-on galaxy. This pair is an example of two similar galaxies at much different orientations. Though these galaxies appear to be interacting they are considered non-interacting pairs due to their significant redshift difference. With a large scope (18” or greater) under dark skies I find this pair to be a stunningly beautiful view.

Attachment 1211

NGC 4754 is unusual as the outer oval is oriented about 45° counter-clockwise from the inner oval and bar. This would seem to indicate an interaction with another galaxy. NED classifies it as SB0^-(r): while the NGC project has it as SB0.

Our target object this week however is NGC 4762. NED classifies it as SB0^0(r)? edge-on, while the NGC project has it as SB?0. It is an exactly edge-on lenticular galaxy, that is perhaps barred or perhaps not barred. Allan Sandage (1961) noted that this is “the flattest form of any galaxy known”. Both ends of the disk have plumes or winglets extending off of them. To have these extensions the conventional wisdom is the galaxy must have interacted with some other galaxy at some point of time.

William Herschel discovered NGC 4762 with an 18.7-inch f/13 speculum telescope. Of his observation of H II-75 (4762) and H II-74 (4754) on March 15, 1784 he recorded, “Two, nearly parallel, the preceding pretty bright, nearly round [4754]. The following [4762] pretty bright, very much extended, 8 or 10’ in distance.” The NGC description is “Pretty bright, very much extended in position angle 31°, 3 bright stars south, following of two.”

Stephen James O’Meara tagged NGC 4762 with the name Paper-Kite in his book The Secret Deep (2011). The name came from a description of the galaxy by Admiral William Henry Smyth in The Bedford Catalog, From A Cycle of Celestial Objects (1844). “This is a fine object, trending south preceding and north following, nearly in the vertical, but from its superior brightness in the south, or upper end, it rises while gazing from the dumpy egg-shape to that of a paper kite: over it is an arch formed by three telescopic stars the symmetry of which is so peculiar as to add to that appearance.”

O’Meara proceeds to explain what makes NGC 4762 so special. “NGC 4762 belongs to the Virgo Cluster of galaxies and is receding from us at 984 km/sec. If we accept its distance of 65 million light-years, the galaxy spans 170,000 light- years across and shines with a luminosity of nearly 1.5 billion Suns. Most peculiar is that images fail to reveal any dust along the galaxy’s razor-sharp edge. This aspect led astronomers early on to classify it as an armless edge-on lenticular (S01) – one consisting of a very small, very bright nucleus in a narrow, high-surface-brightness, flat central disk (1.70 0.10 ) with faint, twisted (S-shaped), brush-like extensions. These details are surrounded by a quite asymmetric thick disk (lens) of gas.”

“Some astronomers suspected that the galaxy may hide a bar in its perfectly flat inner disk. Indeed, some sources classify NGC 4762 as the prototype SB0 galaxy of the flat-bar variety. But in a 1995 Astronomy Letters and Communications (vol. 31, pp. 165–167), Hervé Wozniak (Geneva Observatory, Switzerland, and Marseille Observatory, France) argues that such a system should have a “thick bar,” while NGC 4762 has only a thin central structure. He also notes that the galaxy’s very luminous bulge is too small for a galaxy classified as an “early type.” And why, Wozniak asks, is the galaxy’s outer lens “bluer” than the central “bar”? (Observations of lenses around stellar bars in early-type galaxies show that their colors are the same.) What’s more, in face-on galaxies, bars and lenses have almost the same major axis length, but NGC 4762’s bar is almost 50 percent the length of the lens!”

“To explain these anomalies, the author suggests that NGC 4762 has cannibalized a small satellite galaxy with 10 percent of the host galaxy’s mass; the companion, then, could have could settled inside the host’s disk – distributing its stars partly in the galaxy’s thin central disk and partly in the thick disk (which formed by thermal heating during the merging). NGC 4762 consuming a small companion would also explain the mysterious warping seen in the disk’s extensions. A merger would also explain the blue color of NGC 4762’s lens, as the interaction may have triggered star formation there. “NGC 4762 is thus not a galaxy with a flat edge-on bar,” Wozniak concludes.”

Attachment 1212

Most modern day observations of NGC 4762 with large aperture telescopes note the existence of faint plumes at each end of the galaxy. At the northerly end, the plume extends off to the northeast. At the southerly end, the plume extends off to the southeast. However in researching other amateurs’ observations on the Internet and in print, I found very few that mention these disk extensions.

My sparse notes from a March 2012 observation of NGC 4762 with Barbarella (a large telescope - Jimi’s 48”) read: “Edge-on, very nice galaxy, very bright core, bright straight arms which extend out and then flare or feather at both ends.”

So I challenge you to “Give it a go and let us know.” Share your observations of NGC 4762 and let us know what it takes to see the faint disk extensions of this amazingly flat galaxy.

“GIVE IT A GO AND LET US KNOW”
GOOD LUCK AND GREAT VIEWING!

I observed this pair with my 4" f/5.5 Televue four years ago but did not notice any flaring-out at 4762's ends.

FWIW I had my 90mm f/7.0 Stellarvue Fluorite Triplet out the other night in my backyard. I live in a suburban area of a large metro city. Heavily light polluted; transparency was fair as was seeing. I tried 4762 and 4754. Surprisingly their cores were easily visible as diffuse spots. Beyond that not much else; although once when everything kicked in just right I thought I could detect the ghostly diffusion of lightness extending from the cores.

-Mark

I've observed this cool galaxy several times but only sketched it once so far, and that was using Jimi's 48 inch scope. My notes are uncharacteristically brief:

"Beautiful edge on (galaxy) with feathered ends that are much wider than the rest of the galaxy."

No SQM reading but probably around 21.60. My notes on the next object indicate that the sky was being compromised by high clouds, which is probably why I didn't see the extensions off each end of 4762.

Attachment 1213 Attachment 1214

With 16" the feathered ends were only indicated. With averted vision somewhat unusual conic structure were visible.

16", 284x, NELM 6m5+, Seeing IV
http://www.deepsky-visuell.de/Zeichn...54_NGC4762.jpg

Uwe,

Your sketch is a close approximation of what I see in my 15" under good dark skies. BTW your sketching is excellent. I really should take some time and give it a try. Thanks for sharing.

-Mark

Great object Mark!

I was able to revisit this OOTW (as well as a few others) last night from Green River. In my 25" at 185x and 242x I was able to make out both plumes on either end of the galaxy. The galaxy itself is nicely framed between 3 stars and in the 17 Ethos at 185x I was able to see both 4762 & 4754 in the same field.

Nice pick!

Here's another observation with Jimi's scope on my birthday last year. That scope gets around!

Extremely bright, stunning thin edge-on SW-NE, ~6.0'x0.6'. An extremely thin bright streak extends along the major axis, brightening at the center to a remarkably bright core and stellar nucleus. Beyond the tips of the very high surface portion of the edge-on disc, the galaxy has diffuse extensions at both ends that flare out and appear like water being sprayed out the end of a hose. The extensions increase the length to at least 8'. The bright disc has a sharp edge, particularly on the west side, but a low surface brightness glow is visible on both sides, increasing the width to at least 1' and the overall dimensions to 8'x1'. The southern side of the galaxy is flanked by two mag 9.5 stars and a mag 10.5 star is directly south.

Here are my observations of this beautiful galaxy...

I first observed it with my 18". pretty easy to see, amazingly thin. The distinctly brighter core, although small, certainly stands out. The surface brightness of the arms is quite high. I did not really see detailed flaring, but for sure the ends of the spiral arms were not sharp. Rather, they did appear fuzzy. I tried hard to see "plumes" but the only thing I could readily detect was that the ends were not pointy, rather they were soft.

Attachment 1229

I did also observe this galaxy with my 6" f5.9 achromatic refractor. The galaxy was quite bright, again with a distinctly brighter nucleus. The edges of the spiral arms were definitely sharper than they were in the 18", though not pointy when examined at 128X. This seems to confirm that with the 18" I did really see the flaring, as a softness of the edges of the arms.... Unfortunately, persistant high clouds over the last few days did not allow further observations of the galaxy, hopefully I'll have another chance next new moon...