Results 1 to 10 of 10

Thread: Object of the Week March 10, 2024 – Tiny and Super-Thin in Coma Berenices

  1. #1
    Member deepskytraveler's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2012
    Location
    Wheaton, IL USA
    Posts
    106

    Object of the Week March 10, 2024 – Tiny and Super-Thin in Coma Berenices

    NGC 4147, PGC 38669
    Constellation: Coma Berenices
    Type: Globular Cluster
    RA: 12h 10m 06s
    Dec: +18° 32’ 33”
    Mag: 10.31
    Size: 4.4'

    UGC 7170, PGC 38748, MCG 3-31-55
    Constellation: Coma Berenices
    Type: Spiral Galaxy
    RA: 12h 10m 37s
    Dec: +18° 49’ 42”
    Mag: 14.73
    Size: 3.0’ x 0.2’

    Two contrasting objects this week share the space in a 30” field of view in the constellation Coma Berenices. On the tiny side we visit a globular cluster, NGC 4147. On the super-thin side we visit the galaxy UGC 7170. You’ll find both somewhat challenging targets in all but the largest scopes.

    UGC7170 and NGC4147 JShuder.jpg
    ©J.Shuder

    NGC 4147 is the New General Catalogue identifier for a globular cluster of stars in the northern constellation of Coma Berenices. It was discovered by English astronomer William Herschel on March 14, 1784, who described it as "very bright, pretty large, gradually brighter in the middle". With an apparent visual magnitude of 10.7, it is located around 60,000 light years away from the Sun at a relatively high galactic latitude of 77.2°. This is a relatively small globular cluster, ranking 112th in luminosity among the Milky Way globular cluster population. It is considered an Oosterhoff type I cluster (OoI), despite having a relatively low metallicity. Indeed, it has the lowest metallicity of any OoI cluster known. There are 19 RR Lyrae variable star candidates and as many as 23 blue stragglers. A high proportion of the latter are concentrated near the dense core of the cluster, which is consistent with the idea that blue stragglers form through stellar mergers. The cluster lies some 70.4 ± 7.5 kly (21.6 ± 2.3 kpc) from the Galactic Center, and is relatively isolated from other globular clusters in the galaxy. The position of this cluster makes it a candidate for association with the Sagittarius tidal stream, and thus it may have been captured by the Milky Way after separation from the Sagittarius Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxy. A contour map of the cluster appears to show S-shaped tidal arms stretching to the north and south for several tidal radii. Such features are predicted for globular clusters that follow elliptical orbits and are near their apogalacticon (the point at which we are farthest from the center of the galaxy).

    You will find that NGC 4147 should be visible in scopes 8” and larger; while 16” or more of aperture is necessary to begin resolving stars in this globular cluster. Kepple and Sanner in The Night Sky Observer’s Guide Volume 2 Spring & Summer share these observations of this object.
    • 8”/10” scopes @ 100x: is a moderately faint, diffuse, unresolved glow containing a stellar nucleus
    • 12”/14” scopes @125x: fairly bright, unresolved2.5 diameter sphere with a bright but tiny core; a few field stars stand out around an irregular periphery that seems slightly elongated NE-SW


    NGC4147 HST.jpeg

    With our edge-on view, UGC 7170 is a super-thin spiral galaxy type of Scd. UGC 7170 is classified as a member of the NGC 4155 group of galaxies, which includes NGC 4155, UGC 7170, and UGC 7133. What is really cool about this galaxy (and some other super-thin galaxies such as the “integral-sign galaxy" UGC 3697) is that it has an asymmetric warp that bends more strongly on its southern side than on it northern side. This warp is evident at both optical and 21 cm wavelengths. The similarities of the stellar and gaseous warps are consistent with a gravitational origin for the warp. The relatively small size of the halo core makes it possible to explain the warp as a gravitational bending mode of the galactic disk, if the dark halo is assumed to be slightly flattened.

    My first observation of UGC 7170 (also my first super-thin galaxy) occurred on 23 March 2012. My notes from this observing run were sometimes cryptic or vague, either from extreme tiredness or raging excitement. In this particular case I had not recorded the eyepiece(s) that were used.
    • Barbarella, (Jimi Lowrey’s) 48” f/4 scope: very super thin galaxy, well defined edges, clearly seen

    Alvin Huey shares his observation of UGC 7170.
    • 22” f/4 scope @ 185x, 255x, 306x and 383x: Considerably faint, thin, slightly brighter elongated center and very diffuse tips. Defined edges. PA = 15 and 1.8’ long. A 15.4 mag star lies 0.7’ SSE from the center.


    ugc 7170 crop.jpg
    UGC-7170.gif

    Now it is your turn.
    As always,
    Give it a go and let us know!


    Postscript: The Uppsala General Catalogue of Galaxies (UGC) is an essentially complete catalog of galaxies to a limiting diameter of 1.0 arcminute and/or to a limiting apparent magnitude of 14.5 on the blue prints of the Palomar Observatory Sky Survey (POSS). Coverage is limited to the sky north of declination -02.5 degrees. Galaxies smaller than 1.0 arcminute in diameter but brighter than 14.5 mag may be included from the Catalogue of Galaxies and of Clusters of Galaxies (CGCG, Zwicky et al. 1961-1968); all such galaxies in the CGCG are included in the UGC. The galaxies are numbered in order of their 1950.0 right ascension values. The catalog contains descriptions of the galaxies and their surrounding areas, plus conventional system classifications and position angles for flattened galaxies. Galaxy diameters on both the blue and red POSS prints are included and the classifications and descriptions are given in such a way as to provide as accurate an account as possible of the appearance of the galaxies on the prints.
    Clear Skies,

    Mark Friedman
    Wheaton, IL USA

  2. #2
    Member
    Join Date
    Jun 2014
    Location
    La Serena, Chile
    Posts
    431
    I have observed NGC 4147 with my 20" dob (stars at the edge resolved at 320x) but not UGC 7170. Time for a revisit!
    Clear, dark, transparent skies, Wouter

    20" F/5 custom Dob (Chile)
    12" F/5 custom Dob (Chile)
    12" F/5 Explore Scientific Ultra Light Gen 2 Dob (Spain)
    94 mm SharpStar Refractor (Chile, Spain)

  3. #3
    Member Clear Skies's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2012
    Location
    the Netherlands
    Posts
    294
    A great pair! The galaxy is easily overlooked by many, that I am pretty sure of.

    6 observations in my log for the globular, one for the galaxy:

    NGC4147

    NGC4147_1.jpg NGC4147_2.jpg

    3 observations in the years 2006-2007 using an 8" SCT under Dutch skies. All three tell me the cluster revealed its core and began to resolve at 78x.

    It was to be almost 12 years until my next observations, this time in a 14" from the French Ardennes @ 237x:

    Somewhat resolvable without using AV, the brightest stars are to the SW of the middle. On the SSW edge is a mag. 13 star (4UCAC543-052981), twice that distance towards the NW is a mag. 14. star (4UCAC543-052697). Using AV the cluster is slightly elongated north to south, quite well resolved, slightly flattened on the east side on a line from north to south and slightly more bulging on the west side.

    Two years later, a backyard observation in my 12" @ 191x:

    A grainy glow, quite suddenly slightly brighter in the middle. On the SSW edge is a notable mag. 12.5 ster (4UCAC543-052981). With AV the cluster is larger, the core is slightly larger in which the cluster somewhat resolves and more faint stars are visible surrounding the core. A beautiful cluster.

    I blogged about that session, too.

    Final observation, in 2022, was again using my 14" SCT, but this time from the Alps. Magnification again 237x. As my notes tell me, the cluster did not appear perfectly round:

    Not very large and not very bright, not completely round, slightly elongated NNE to SSW and brightest directly SSW of the middle, slightly tapering towards the SW. The cluster is grainy, using AV quite a few stars resolve in the core that clearly stretches slightly towards the SSW, surrounded by a faint glow of unresolved stars that is clearest to the north and to the east of the middle. A nice cluster.

    Here's the blog for that freezing session. It was that observing run when I also bagged the galaxy.

    MCG+03-31-055

    MCG+03-31-055_1.jpg MCG+03-31-055_2.jpg MCG+03-31-055_3.jpg

    Magnification was 168x:

    An extremely faint, NNE-SSW elongated glow, at the limit of visibility with AV but clearly very elongated, even in brightness, no detail visible.
    1/2 FoV to the north is the galaxy NGC4155.

    The observing guides depicted above can be downloaded here.
    Victor van Wulfen

    clearskies.eu - Clear Skies Observing Guides - CSOG - Blog - Observing Log - Observing Sessions

    SQM is nothing, transparency is everything.

  4. #4
    Member lamperti's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2012
    Location
    Royersford, PA
    Posts
    159
    UGC-7170: With a 20" at 318x + Galaxy Contrast Enhancement filter:"I can see three stars in a row that help guide to the location. It is easy to see as the telescope was slowly slewing to the position. PA ~0 [12].

    NGC-4147: Also with a 20" at 272:"Can see resolution around the edges. I estimated class 7-10 with Uranometria = 6)."
    15" f4.5 Obsession Classic
    4" f8.6 Televue 102

  5. #5
    Member Howard B's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2012
    Location
    Scappoose, Oregon USA
    Posts
    572
    I have one observation of each object:

    NGC 4147
    "This small globular is difficult to resolve, but I did so with the 11mm (and averted vision). 20-inch f/5, 231x, no SQM."

    UGC 7170
    "This is a really low contrast edge-on galaxy! Not at all obvious - if I didn't know exactly where it's located I'd pass it by. 28-inch f/4, 253x, 21.20 SQM"
    Howard
    30-inch f/2.7 alt-az Newtonian
    https://sites.google.com/site/howardbanichhomepage/
    https://sites.google.com/site/sprays...pemirrors/home
    Contributing Editor, Sky & Telescope magazine

  6. #6
    Member Raul Leon's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2018
    Location
    Tampa Florida
    Posts
    190
    Hi, here's my observation from :5/19/2012: ngc 4147 is a globular cluster in Coma Berenice ; mag:10.4 ; size: 4.4' ; partially resolved, has a small bright core. I used a 7mm Nagler at 250x with my 14.5 StarStructure.
    4147.jpg
    Raul Leon
    14.5 Starstructure Dobsonian f/4.3

    http://thestarsketcher.blogspot.com/

  7. #7
    Member Steve Gottlieb's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2012
    Location
    Northern California
    Posts
    808
    I've seen both of these a few times, but NGC 4147 really came to life (compared to previous views) in Jimi's 48-inch:

    NGC 4147, a class IX globular, was well resolved and impressive at 488x. It appeared very bright, fairly large, large bright core. Over 100 stars were resolved including a number of relatively bright 14.5-15.5 stars. The stellar density increases significantly towards the center where a large number of resolved stars are packed over a hazy, mottled background. The loose halo was well resolved, a bit scraggly around the edges and extended to ~5' diameter. The superthin galaxy UGC 7170 lies 18' NNE.

    UGC 7170 was pretty ghostly in my 18-inch: Extremely faint and thin sliver with a slightly brighter core, 1.4'x0.15'. Sometimes only the core stood out but often the needle-thin extensions would pop into view.
    Steve
    24" f/3.7 Starstructure
    18" f/4.3 Starmaster
    Adventures in Deep Space
    Contributing Editor, Sky & Tel

  8. #8
    Member cloudbuster's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2019
    Location
    Almere, The Netherlands
    Posts
    27
    NGC 4147 (or NGC 4153) was observed 4 years ago from my home country with the 16" and 7mm XW @ 259x. SQM was 21.1
    This is a small cluster, but can easily be seen with a grainy structure even in the core. The shape is somewhat triangular, a feeling that is amplified because of three a bit brighter stars within the cluster at the corners.

    NGC 4147.jpg
    Last edited by cloudbuster; March 12th, 2024 at 09:55 AM.
    Martijn
    www.deepskysketch.com
    16" F/3.8 & 10" F/4.8 Sumerian Alkaid travel dob on EQ-platform / Omegon Argus 16 x 70 on Orion Paragon-plus / Swift Audubon 8,5 x 44 / Vixen SG 2.1 x 42

  9. #9
    Member FaintFuzzies's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2012
    Location
    Hill Country Texas
    Posts
    247
    Nice object Mark. I enjoyed observing the superthins from about 2010-2014. I managed to observe almost all from my list, maybe 15 left.
    Clear skies,
    Alvin #26
    FaintFuzzies.com
    Texas Hill Country

  10. #10
    Member
    Join Date
    Feb 2012
    Location
    Germany
    Posts
    819
    My only observation was nearly 20 years ago with my former but new at the time 16-inch. Under rural skies with limited transparency but steady seeing I wrote:

    NGC 4147 immediately visible as a small glob, somewhat loose concentration, with 270x nicely but not fully resolved
    UGC 7170 only visible with averted vision, not steadily visible, edge on character only suggested, axle ratio not sure definable
    Clear Skies, uwe
    http://www.deepsky-visuell.de
    Germany

    27" f/4,2

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •